America Took a Simple Girl Scout Treat and Turned It Into a Billion-Dollar Flavor
S'mores started in a 1927 Girl Scout handbook. Here's how they became America's most beloved campfire treat.
America Took a Simple Girl Scout Treat and Turned It Into a Billion-Dollar Flavor
5 min
Prep
5 min
Bake
8
Makes
- 8 full sheets graham crackers
each sheet breaks into 4 squares — 2 squares per smore
- 8 large marshmallows
Jet-Puffed standard size — the size matters for melt ratio
- 2 standard (1.55 oz each) milk chocolate bars
Hersheys is the original — thin bars soften from the marshmallow heat without fully melting
- 1
Break each full graham cracker sheet in half along the scored center line to get 2 rectangles. Each smore uses 2 rectangles as top and bottom.
- 2
Break the chocolate bar into sections sized to fit the graham cracker. Lay one piece on one rectangle — this becomes your base.
- 3
CAMPFIRE METHOD: Skewer a marshmallow on a long stick or roasting fork. Hold it over glowing coals — not flames. Flames char the outside before the inside melts. Rotate slowly and patiently. A properly roasted marshmallow takes 2-3 minutes to go golden-brown all over.
- 4
When the marshmallow is deeply golden and beginning to sag from the heat, place it directly on the chocolate. Use the top graham cracker to slide the marshmallow off the stick while pressing down firmly.
- 5
Hold the assembled smore together for 15-20 seconds. The marshmallow heat softens the chocolate beneath it. Eat immediately.
- 6
BROILER METHOD: Preheat broiler to high. Place graham crackers with chocolate on a baking sheet. Set a marshmallow on top. Broil 60-90 seconds watching constantly — they go from pale to scorched in seconds. Remove the moment they are golden and beginning to puff. Top with the second graham cracker and press.
Baker's Notes
The campfire method is slow — that is the point. The chocolate does not fully melt, it softens just enough from the marshmallow heat. The Hersheys bar is not sentimental: its thin, waxy formula is designed to soften without running at marshmallow temperatures. Fancier chocolate will slide straight out.
Original: Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts, 1927
America Took a Simple Girl Scout Treat and Turned It Into a Billion-Dollar Flavor
The s'more is a convergence. It requires three ingredients, each with its own strange history in American food culture, each arriving through a completely different route, each bearing the marks of the industrial age. To understand the s'more fully, you have to understand the graham cracker, the marshmallow, and the Hershey bar separately — because none of them were invented for pleasure. They arrived at the campfire through morality, medicine, and mass production, and they found each other by accident around a Girl Scout fire in the 1920s.
Sylvester Graham and the Moral Cracker
The graham cracker was invented by a man who thought pleasure was sinful. Sylvester Graham was a Presbyterian minister and dietary reformer who became one of the more influential — and genuinely strange — figures in nineteenth-century American health culture. Graham believed with considerable conviction that diet was directly connected to moral behavior, and specifically that rich, stimulating food inflamed the passions and contributed to the spiritual decay he saw spreading through young American men.
His prescriptions were systematic and severe. Coarse whole wheat bread, baked at home with unbolted flour — not purchased from commercial bakeries, which he considered corrupt and adulterated. No meat. No spices. No alcohol. Cold baths. Fresh air. A diet designed to suppress appetite and temptation rather than satisfy either.
In the 1820s and 1830s, Graham traveled extensively, lecturing on his dietary principles to audiences who found him compelling enough to change their eating habits. Boardinghouses in New York and Boston adopted his principles. His followers became known as Grahamites. His name became attached to the coarse whole wheat cracker he advocated: the Graham cracker.
Graham crackers as he intended them bore almost no resemblance to the sweet, honey-flavored wafers on grocery store shelves today. The original was dense, dry, and deliberately unpalatable — a cracker engineered to be consumed, not enjoyed. The goal was exactly the opposite of what the modern product delivers. The fact that his cracker became the base of one of the most beloved sweet treats in American food history — a treat built around maximizing pleasure — is one of the funnier ironies the historical record contains.
The Marshmallow, From Medicine to Candy
Marshmallows also did not begin as candy. The marsh mallow plant (Althaea officinalis) is a species native to Europe and western Asia whose root produces a thick, mucilaginous substance that ancient Egyptians extracted and combined with honey and nuts to make a sweet medicinal confection. This was pharaonic-era medicine, not snack food. The confection was reserved for gods and royalty, consumed for its healing properties, particularly for treating sore throats and coughs.
The marsh mallow plant stayed associated with medicine through the ancient and medieval periods. European apothecaries dispensed it as a remedy. The candy potential of the mallow extract was recognized by French confectioners in the nineteenth century, who developed a labor-intensive process of whipping the root extract with egg whites and sugar into a soft foam that could be piped into molds and set. The result was expensive to produce and sold in small quantities at high prices. Marshmallows were a luxury.
The industrial breakthrough came around 1900, when American and European candy manufacturers discovered that gelatin could replace the mallow root extract entirely. Gelatin — derived from animal collagen — produced the same soft, foamy, elastic texture at a fraction of the cost and at scales that handmade production could never approach. Starch extrusion processes allowed marshmallows to be manufactured continuously in large automated batches. The Angelus Marshmallow Company began commercial marshmallow production in the United States in 1917.
By the early 1920s, the marshmallow had completed one of the more remarkable transformations in food history: from a pharaonic medicine made from a wetland plant, to a French luxury confection, to a mass-market American candy available at any general store for almost nothing. The Jet-Puffed bag became a pantry staple.
Milton Hershey and Democratic Chocolate
Before Milton Hershey, chocolate in America was largely an upper-class product. European chocolatiers made small-batch confections sold at high prices in specialty shops. Chocolate as food that ordinary working people consumed regularly — as a matter of course, not as a special occasion — did not really exist in the United States before 1900.
Hershey built his fortune first in caramels, then turned his attention to milk chocolate and built a factory town in the Pennsylvania farmland — a company town he called Hershey, Pennsylvania — specifically designed to produce milk chocolate at a scale that would make it affordable to everyone. The infrastructure was massive and intentional: a factory powered by a dedicated electrical plant, a company town with housing for workers, and a supply chain built around the excess fresh milk produced by Pennsylvania dairy farms.
The Hershey Milk Chocolate Bar launched in 1900 at five cents. The formula used fresh milk rather than the dried milk powder common in European chocolate production, and the production process involved a controlled partial souring of the milk — a characteristic that gave Hershey chocolate a slightly tangy, distinctive flavor profile that American consumers came to recognize as what chocolate tasted like. European chocolate connoisseurs have always found the profile unusual. American consumers raised on it find European milk chocolate slightly flat in comparison. The difference is real. The debate about which is correct is ongoing and essentially tribal.
The point is not the flavor debate. The point is that Hershey made chocolate accessible to people who had never been able to afford it. By 1920, the Hershey bar was in every drug store, every general store, every corner market in the country. It went into American soldier rations in both World Wars. For millions of Americans, the Hershey bar was simply what chocolate meant.
The Girl Scouts and the Campfire
Juliette Gordon Low founded the Girl Scouts of the USA in Savannah, Georgia in 1912, modeling the organization partly on Robert Baden-Powell's scouting movement in Britain but shaping it specifically for American girls around principles of outdoor competence, community service, and practical self-reliance. Camping was central to Scout identity from the beginning. Learning to live outdoors, build fires, and cook without a kitchen was the point, not a supplementary activity.
In 1927, the Girl Scouts published a guidebook called "Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts." It was a practical outdoor manual covering camping skills, hiking, and campfire cooking. Buried in its pages was a recipe for a campfire treat the book called "Some Mores." The recipe was exactly what you would expect: graham crackers, a chocolate bar, a marshmallow toasted over the fire, pressed together. The name referred to the immediate response the treat provoked — everyone wanted some more.
The recipe was not presented as an invention. It was written as a known thing — a recipe readers were assumed to understand or would easily grasp. Which suggests that the s'more, or something very close to it, was already in circulation among campfire cooks before 1927. The Girl Scout guidebook documented it rather than created it. But documentation is how recipes survive and spread, and the 1927 guidebook is where the trail begins in the written record.
The contraction from "some mores" to "s'mores" happened gradually through American usage over the following decades, reaching the standardized spelling sometime in the mid-twentieth century.
The Convergence That Should Not Have Worked
The s'more is not a recipe that any single person designed with intention. It is a convergence — three mass-market industrial products that happened to all be available by the 1920s, combined around a campfire by people who were experimenting with what you could cook over an open fire.
Sylvester Graham's moral health cracker, stripped of its original austere purpose and sweetened by subsequent manufacturers into something he would have found disgraceful. A medicinal plant from ancient Egypt, industrialized via gelatin into a five-cent bag of marshmallows at the general store. Milton Hershey's democratic chocolate bar, thin enough to soften from the heat of a marshmallow without melting completely. None of them were made for each other. They found each other at a campfire.
The technical reason the combination works is straightforward: the toasted marshmallow transfers enough heat to the adjacent chocolate to soften it slightly but not melt it completely. The chocolate goes from brittle to pliable, releasing its fat and flavor into the warm marshmallow without running. The graham cracker provides crunch, structure, and a subtle honey-wheat backbone that keeps the whole thing from being pure sweetness. Press it together and you have something that behaves completely differently from any of its components in isolation.
What It Became
The s'more became shorthand for a specific American outdoor experience — the campfire, the summer night, the simple pleasure of something sweet and warm made with almost no skill. That association made it extraordinarily durable as a cultural image. You can put s'more flavoring into anything — ice cream, cereal, protein bars, cocktails, baking mixes — and invoke the campfire immediately. The flavor is powerful enough to carry its own nostalgia.
The commercial extensions of s'mores flavor constitute a genuinely massive category in American food marketing. S'mores-flavored products have been documented across at least forty-five distinct food and beverage categories. None of them require a fire. Most of them are pale substitutes for the real thing.
The real thing requires fire, or at minimum a broiler and attention. It requires the transformation that heat causes — the marshmallow going from room-temperature foam to a gold-brown exterior with a liquid interior that collapses when pressed, the chocolate softening against the hot marshmallow, the cracker holding together long enough to eat. The process is the point. The patience is the point. The moment when the marshmallow is exactly right and you have to move quickly is the point.
Sylvester Graham would have hated every second of it. Which makes it all the better.
You just learned the history.
Now make it From Scratch.
Every dish I document, I cook. Below are the exact tools, cookware, and ingredients I used to bring this recipe to life — sourced, tested, and trusted. No guesswork.
The full recipe, 2,000-word history essay, step-by-step photos, and a printable PDF are all waiting for you at alexanderdeyo.com/from-scratch. When you shop through these links, you support the series at no extra cost.
Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bars
Honey Maid Graham Crackers
Jet-Puffed Marshmallows
Cast Iron Camp Skillet
As an Amazon Associate, From Scratch earns from qualifying purchases.
Every meal has a story.
New episodes, 2,000-word food histories, and tested recipes delivered to your inbox. Free forever.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
From Scratch by Alex Deyo
